Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Jewish Business News


Smart Phones & Trolls: The Current State of the Patent Wars

Patent Trolls The Hobbit Wikimedia Commons

Please help us out :
Will you offer us a hand? Every gift, regardless of size, fuels our future.
Your critical contribution enables us to maintain our independence from shareholders or wealthy owners, allowing us to keep up reporting without bias. It means we can continue to make Jewish Business News available to everyone.
You can support us for as little as $1 via PayPal at
Thank you.

Microsoft, Apple and Blackberry, unable to halt Android’s Smartphone dominance (81% global market share in Q3, 2013), adopted a new tactic to topple Google- becoming patent trolls. Based on a portfolio of mobile patents acquired from Nortel in 2011 for $4.5 billion ($750, 000 per patent), their Rockstar consortium filed suit last week against Google, Samsung and other Android players.  It will now be in the hands of a jury in the Eastern District of Texas, a rural district whose overwhelming tendency to rule in favor of patent infringement has made it the most popular US jurisdiction for patent litigation.

In reality, despite suing, and countersuing, one another worldwide over the last few years, little has been resolved. Google further protected its patent position by acquiring Motorola last year, and its 17, 000 mobile related patents.  So what is the future for Smartphone IP?

Marshall Phelps , who previously led IP Strategy at both IBM and Microsoft, shared his views this week at the AIPPI conference  in Tel Aviv. “Within 10 years, the Smartphone platform wars will be over, replaced by a series of licensing arrangements. I have seen estimates of 10’s of thousands of patents implicated in the Smartphone situation. With that much intellectual property involved, no one can realistically build a Smartphone risk-free or without the IP of others”.


Today, some 60% of patent litigation is driven by entities which do not produce anything or compete in any particular industry. This group of patent litigators is referred to as “Non-Practicing Entities” or NPE’s.

The America Invents Act, passed by Congress in 2011 was supposed to address some of the NPE litigation abuses.  According to Randall Rader, Chief Judge for the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, and another AIPPI speaker, reform is needed to “protect the benefits of a robust innovation policy and in part to simply correct injusticethe definition of troll will always be over inclusive or under inclusive to the detriment of justice”.


Trevor Cook, Chairman of the British Copyright Council and Partner at Bird & Bird, cited the emerging importance of the Unified Patent Court  in Europe and how it will affect patent litigation. For example, many believe the “British model”, or imposing fee reversal in cases of abuse, could limit some of the more egregious cases. The US system does not force plaintiffs to pay the costs and fees of the defendant.

The final word in the matter will be left to Steve Wozniak, Apple’s co-Founder, who recently told the BBC, “there are good things I see on Samsung phones that I wish were on my iPhoneI wish everyone just did a lot of cross-licensing and sharing the good technology. All our products would be better. We’d go further”. Until that happens, the trolls have the advantage.





You May Also Like

World News

In the 15th Nov 2015 edition of Israel’s good news, the highlights include:   ·         A new Israeli treatment brings hope to relapsed leukemia...


The Movie The Professional is what made Natalie Portman a Lolita.


After two decades without a rating system in Israel, at the end of 2012 an international tender for hotel rating was published.  Invited to place bids...

VC, Investments

You may not become a millionaire, but there is a lot to learn from George Soros.