Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Jewish Business News


Now Carl Icahn Takes On eBay : Demands 2 Seats On The Board And Spin Off Of PayPal

Master strategist, publicist and pretty good stock picker,  Carl Icahn has been taking more than a passing look at another prestige silicon valley favourite this week, not just Apple.

Giant internet trading site eBay Incannounced yesterday that Carl Icahn has made a proposal to its Board of Directors to nominate two directors on his behalf at their forthcoming Annual Gereal Meeting.

eBay also disclosed that Icahn has also formally proposed they should split out their payment processing subsidiary PayPal, either to third parties or spin it out to the company’s shareholders.

Finally, eBay disclosed that Carl Icahn had revealed to them he owned about a 0.82% economic interest in the company through derivative transactions (usually accomplished using swaps). With a market cap of about US$71 billion that implies his position cost him somewhere around US$582 million – pocket change these days for the right to push around a big company, under the standard activist playbook.


2nd Annual "David Moore's Funny Business Show"

Carl Icahn / Getty

Well the eBay Board of Directors was far from overwhelmed by the proposals it seems, and this is what they said, quite forcefully as these statements go, in response, first with respect to his board nominees:

eBay welcomes the opportunity to listen to the perspective of all of its shareholders, including Mr. Icahn. His Board nominations will be passed on to the Board’s Corporate Governance and Nominating Committee, which will consider them in the ordinary course of business. We would note that eBay has a world-class board of directors with directors who have significant experience in technology and financial services.”

Concise and quite “tart” one can say, and eBay then continued with respect to the idea of splitting out PayPal,

eBay’s Board of Directors routinely assesses the company’s strategic direction and has explored in depth a spinoff or separation of PayPal. eBay’s Board of Directors has concluded that the company and its shareholders are best served by the current strategic direction of the company and does not believe that breaking up the company is the best way to maximize shareholder value.”

In short they said no. Since Carl Icahn must have known they would do this, and since he is already something of a media darling for his recent moves, it again brings him a boatload of free publicity. The company’s shares got a 2% boost following the announcement, which was accompanied by its fourth quarter financial results, which continued to show moderate improvements.

In an accompanying corporate blog post, which is how companies can do their own PR on the internet these days without having to depend on the outside media, subsidiary PayPal chipped in as well saying, “PayPal is successful precisely because we are part of eBay Inc., not in spite of it, ”…“eBay Inc. has helped drive our success for more than a decade, and we continue to believe we’re far more valuable together.”

Of course, what else would they say of their own parent company, but even so the point is made.

Spinning out PayPal as an independent company has in a way been on the table ever since eBay bought it in late 2002 shortly after Elon Musk had cashed out by taking it public, as it both fits and doesn’t fit with what eBay does.

For PayPal itself, part of the logic for being independent is that eBay’s rivals may be more willing to use the payments service if it weren’t part of their competition. “Sometimes PayPal’s attachment to eBay can be a deterrent for eBay’s indirect competitors, ” RJ Hottovy, an equity analyst at Morningstar, told Reuters as long ago as 2012. “That’s the main reason why PayPal should be separated.”

So Carl Icahn likely does not expect to prevail here either, but the attention should certainly help bring focus to eBay and its prospects, which he probably again believes he may benefit from in any case.

In addition, and coming completely from left field, is the whole issue of internet payment systems using mobile smart phones, as iOS and Android methodologies are improving rapidly both in capabilities and security, something increasingly referred to colloquially as the “digital wallet”.

Beyond even this, there is the potential for radical disruption of all banking services using the internet if virtual currencies such as bitcoin should obtain more than a toehold. In this evolving context there is good reason to believe that PayPal itself has a chance to become a key player – whether inside or outside of eBay.


1 Comment

1 Comment

  1. PhilipCohen

    January 25, 2014 at 12:01 am

    Johnny Ho Momentarily Inflates eBay Stock Price with Hot Air from Disclosure of Proposal from Carl Icahn
    “Proposal from Carl Icahn — The company also announced today that it has received a notice from Carl Icahn indicating that he has nominated two of his employees to its Board of Directors and submitted a non-binding proposal for a spinoff of its PayPal business into a separate company. …”
    What a total non story! Still, Johnny Ho had to figure out some way to try to get some hot air into the moribund eBay stock. Separately corporatize “PreyPal”? Not likely!
    As great a fool as Johnny Ho is, he does at least know that “PreyPal” contributes ~40% of eBay’s value, and without “PreyPal”, eBay would simply continue on its Donahoe-directed journey down the toilet—at an even faster rate.
    Likewise, Johnny Ho appreciates—as apparently Carl Icahn does not—that separated from eBay, the clunky “PreyPal” would be effectively cut off at the knees, particularly so now that MasterCard and Visa have launched their own “professional” digital wallets …
    Regardless, both eBay and “PreyPal” are destined to continue their journeys to the sewage farm.
    The fact is, notwithstanding the amount of noise that emanates from the eBay Dept of Spin, it is estimated that “PreyPal” has only a little more than one percent (~1%) of the world’s total payments business; MasterCard and Visa have ~90% thereof between them and Amex has another ~8%. Anyone that thinks that “PreyPal” has any chance of taking any more micro fractions of the payments market away from MasterCard/Visa/Amex, is obviously living in the same Wonderland that Alice and Johnny Ho live in …
    Goodbye clunky “PreyPal”, it has not been nice knowing you …
    The ugly details of eBay’s clunky, unscrupulous “PreyPal” operation …
    Then there is the demonstrable, massive, eBay-facilitated and aided and abetted, before and after the fact, criminal activity on eBay marketplace auctions …
    The ugly details of eBay eBay’s crooked auctions marketplace … 
    The ugly details of eBay Motors (UK sampling): Auction Fraud Galore … 
    Regardless, the fact remains that if, in August 2007, before Johnny Ho actively started his “destructive renovations”, when both eBay’s and Amazon’s stock was ~$40/share, had Pierre Omidyar traded in all his eBay shares for shares in Amazon, instead of ~$4.7 billion, he would now be worth ~43 billion dollars! Now that, surely, is something for all existing or potential major “long” eBay investors to think about, is it not?
    Icahn’s investment/proposal does not alter the reality that the majority of the “smart money” on Wall Street obviously considers eBay to be a “dog” and that Johnny Ho to be a very poor dog handler—otherwise, like Amazon, eBay too would be valued at ~$400/share.
    Further, that the “Headless Ho” could give a tutorial to anyone about anything—particularly on technology—is simply too funny; still, it seems that Johnny Ho and Carl Icahn could make a good fit—both are looking out only for themselves.
    “Even though people think I’m an expert at technological innovation, my own instinct for technology was frozen in place in 1982.” – John Donahoe (26 Sep 2007) …
    [On the first part, who could possibly think that? On the second, a few of the only true words that Johnny Ho has ever spoken …]
    eBay / PayPal / Donahoe: Dead Men Walking …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.



You May Also Like

World News

In the 15th Nov 2015 edition of Israel’s good news, the highlights include:   ·         A new Israeli treatment brings hope to relapsed leukemia...


The contract signed between the Israeli government and Pfizer shows clearly and unequivocally that this is a clinical study on humans - The agreement...


After two decades without a rating system in Israel, at the end of 2012 an international tender for hotel rating was published.  Invited to place bids...


Now Platika joins and elite club of $10 billion plus Israeli firms.